- Date: August 23-24, 2025
- Partner: Ross Bricklemyer, Jennifer Reneker
- Height: 14,061 feet
- Range: San Juan
- Route: Chicago Basin Approach and South Face (Class 4)
- Overall Distance: 17 miles
- Elevation Gain: 6,000 feet (train to summit)
- 14ers climbed: 49 separate climbs
- 14ers remaining: 4
- Road Condition to Trailhead: Get ready for the craziest drive to the “trailhead” you’ve ever had. From Durango, you will hop on the Durango & Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad. Call the railroad in advance to reserve a special Wilderness Access/Needleton hiker drop-off ticket. You and your backpack will take the scenic train about 30 miles north along the Animas River to the Needleton stop (~2.5 hours).
In August 2018, I was roundly trounced in an attempt to do a solo summit of Sunlight Peak. Long story short, I was right at the Leap of Faith with a storm brewing and did not feel comfortable attempting the move by myself on slippery rock. The 14.5-mile hike back to Purgatory Flats in a driving rain only served to add salt to my wounds. This fearful memory of the mountain, and what has been called the most exposed move among the 14ers, haunted my dreams for seven years.
Fast forward to 2025 and I decided to try my luck again. However, this time I would be much better prepared. First off, I would go with someone who was experienced in the mountains, my Appalachian Trail partner Ross Bricklemyer. I spent lots of time studying the route and trying to collect as much information as I could about the Leap of Faith. Eventually, after much back-and-forth with Ross, we decided that we would treat this as a rock climb and prepare accordingly. We were able to work with the owner of New River Mountain Guides, Elaina Arenz, to set up a shakedown session in the New River Gorge near Fayetteville, West Virginia a few weeks before the climb. Working with guides Jeffery Hearn and Brian Sabourin, we were able to spend a day simulating the moves on the Sunlight Peak summit pitch and get ready with the appropriate gear. Ross and I are very much indebted to them for all their help and encouragement. If you are ever in the area, please book a trip with them.
In any event, the time came to head to Colorado. Joining us would be my friend/co-worker Jennifer Reneker. I guess the “bad news” would be that this was her first time tackling a 14er (and she chose a dandy!), but the “good news” was that she was in very good shape. This was not going to be a vacation but rather an adventure. The three of us flew to Durango from Denver on August 22, with Jennifer and I coming by way of Cleveland, Ohio, and Ross coming from St. Louis, Missouri. As I described in my Windom Peak post from 2019, even getting to the Chicago Basin for this approach is quite the adventure; I will refrain from describing that again here.
On Saturday, August 23, the three of us left the Needleton train stop, crossed the Animas River on the suspension bridge, and set off up the trail toward Chicago Basin. Ross played the role of the jackrabbit, racing out ahead to find a good campsite before anyone else might claim it. This approach is not a chip shot. It is a good 6 miles, and almost 3,000 feet of ascent, along Needle Creek up into the Chicago Basin, with full packs. You will know you’ve done something when you stop. The day became seriously warm and Jennifer and I had to take a few rest stops to rehydrate in the high altitude.
Near the upper end of the basin, around 11,200 feet, Ross had found a dandy campsite to the right, very near the trail junction to Twin Lakes. We set up our tents and laid around for a few hours chatting and eating. I would have been lucky to have been the recipient of even a few hours of sleep that night. I think I was both too anxious and too excited.
Because of a very compressed schedule, we left Chicago Basin quite early; that is, in the dark. We had a few points along the way were we had to search for cairns but for the most part it was an uneventful, steep climb up well-defined trail to Twin Lakes (12,500′).
From Twin Lakes, we veered to the right, followed the trail around the first lake, then climbed switchbacks into the upper basin. By now the sun had appeared and the morning was beautiful. Above 13,000 feet, we followed cairns east, then angled left across the basin toward the gully between Sunlight Peak and Sunlight Spire. While the trail petered out here, it was pretty obvious what had to take place to get to the summit ridge. We climbed an oppressively nasty and steep gully to the saddle, then turned left into a notch. You will have to be careful here and frequently refer to your map and pictures of the route downloaded from 14ers.com (you surely have those with you, right?!).
The final section to Sunlight Peak involves Class 3 climbing, route finding, and significant exposure. Again, it is easy to get off track here, so take your time. From the notch, the three of us climbed and traversed beneath some cliffs and stayed to our left. We then continued up steep rock, located a small chimney with a hole at the top, climbed through it, then turned left toward the summit block. Jennifer had done a remarkable job the whole climb; it was hard to believe she had never done this before. There was the last summit pitch, now 8.5 miles from the trailhead, a scene I had pictured in my mind 1,000 times over the past seven years.
The last summit pitch is dangerously exposed but was dry and had a solid gritty grip. We changed over to climbing shoes and did some initial reconnoitering. Ross then stemmed over from the Leap of Faith platform to the Left Slab trailing a Sterling 30-meter climbing rope. He scrambled to the top of the Left Slab and hip belayed me straight up the face. Both of these steps were made with total confidence (frankly due to the training we had with New River Mountain Guides). From there Ross and I both took turns crawling out to the summit itself. Ross then belayed me down to the bottom of the Left Slab using his belay device. Not feeling great about setting a hand-line due to lack of pronounced rock features, Ross decided to simply stem back over to the Leap of Faith platform. All of this was done without hesitation, and with calm expediency. The climbing rope and climbing shoes were excellently suited for this climb.
Jennifer, Ross, and I had little time to celebrate because we had to catch the southbound train from Silverton heading back to Durango. Missing this train would mean spending another night in the Weminuche Wilderness. That meant grabbing a quick bite to eat, and then gingerly retracing our steps back to Twin Lakes, slipping and sliding from time-to-time on the loose, sandy fine rock prevalent on the steep gully slope. Scurrying down to our tents, we quickly broke down camp and filled our backpacks with our gear, and then set off to Needleton at a fast clip. It rained on and off toward the last hour, but that did not dampen our spirits and we made it to Needleton with about 30 minutes to spare to catch the train.
This was the last of the San Juan Mountains for me and I will never forget the smell of the wildflowers, the remoteness, the alpenglow, the mountain goats, and the feeling I had finally getting to the summit of Sunlight Peak. If it were not for the Leap of Faith, I would give this an 8 on a scale of difficulty. However, the last summit pitch move puts it at a 9. If you want to hear more detail on the last summit pitch move, then I would be happy to help if you leave a message and contact information in the comments.